EmailMeForm
MCFOA Coaches Evaluation Report - Revised 8/2015
Please use this form to evaluate the crew, by position.
Name and Position of Person Submitting this Report
*
Contact Phone Number for MCFOA President to Call with Questions:
*
###
-
###
-
####
Game Date
*
MM
/
DD
/
YYYY
Home Team and Score
*
Visiting Team and Score
*
CREW -
Overall impression of the entire crew?
*
Outstanding
Above Average
Average
Below Average
Poor
CREW -
Overall - Rate the crew's knowledge of the rules
*
Administered the rules correctly throughout game
Administered most rules correctly - made a minor mistake
Misinterpreted a rule that had a noticable impact on the game
Misinterpreted the administration of several rules during the game
Referee Name
*
Referee communication
*
Outstanding
Above Average
Average
Below Average
Poor
Good communication is the talking with crew, effectively managing communication with coaches, signaling when appropriate and using proper signals on penalties.
Overall, how would you rate the presence of the referee?
*
Outstanding
Above Average
Average
Below Average
Poor
Presence is overall appearance, ability to communicate with coaches, and his professionalism.
Referee's understanding of the rules and overall game management
*
Clearly understood the rules and managed the game efficiently and effectively
Understood the rules, but did not manage the game as effectively
Managed the game well, but made rule related mistakes that impacted the game
Made multiple mistakes impacting several plays both in rules application and management
Game management is knowing the rules, the overall status of the game, and the ability to use effective judgement given the situation.
Overall Comments about the Referee:
Umpire Name
Umpire communication
*
Outstanding
Above Average
Average
Below Average
Poor
Good communication is talking with wings and referee to know down, distance and status of ball at all times. Using proper signals to signify down, player count and center protection.
Overall, how would you rate the presence of the umpire?
*
Outstanding
Above Average
Average
Below Average
Poor
Presence is overall appearance, ability to communicate with crew, and his professionalism.
Umpire's understanding of the rules and overall game management
*
Clearly understood the rules and managed the game efficiently and effectively
Understood the rules, but did not manage the game as effectively
Managed the game well, but made bad call(s) that impacted the game
Made multiple mistakes impacting several plays both in rules application and management
Game management is knowing the rules, the overall status of the game, and the ability to use effective judgement given the situation.
Overall Comments about the Umpire:
Head Linesman Name
Head Linesman communication
*
Outstanding
Above Average
Average
Below Average
Poor
Good communication is talking with other wing and referee to know down, distance and status of ball at all times. Using proper signals to signify line count and down.
Overall, how would you rate the presence of the Head Linesman?
*
Outstanding
Above Average
Average
Below Average
Poor
Presence is overall appearance, ability to communicate with crew, and his professionalism.
Head Linesman's understanding of the rules and overall game management
*
Clearly understood the rules and managed the game efficiently and effectively
Understood the rules, but did not manage the game as effectively
Managed the game well, but made bad call(s) that impacted the game
Made multiple mistakes impacting several plays both in rules application and management
Game management is knowing the rules, the overall status of the game, and the ability to use effective judgement given the situation.
Overall Comments about the Head Linesman:
Line Judge Name
Optional Comments regarding the Line Judge's Pre-Game or In-Game Mechanics
Line Judge communication
*
Outstanding
Above Average
Average
Below Average
Poor
Good communication is talking with other wing and referee to know down, distance and status of ball at all times. Using proper signals to signify line count and down.
Overall, how would you rate the presence of the Line Judge?
*
Outstanding
Above Average
Average
Below Average
Poor
Presence is overall appearance, ability to communicate with crew, and his professionalism.
Line Judge's understanding of the rules and overall game management
*
Clearly understood the rules and managed the game efficiently and effectively
Understood the rules, but did not manage the game as effectively
Managed the game well, but made bad call(s) that impacted the game
Made multiple mistakes impacting several plays both in rules application and management
Game management is knowing the rules, the overall status of the game, and the ability to use effective judgement given the situation.
Overall Comments about the Line Judge:
Field Judge Name
Field Judge communication
*
Outstanding
Above Average
Average
Below Average
Poor
Good communication is talking with other deep official and assisting with side line management. Demonstrating knowledge of the down, distance and status of ball at all times. Using proper signals to signify defensive player count and down.
Overall, how would you rate the presence of the Field Judge?
*
Outstanding
Above Average
Average
Below Average
Poor
Presence is overall appearance, ability to communicate with crew, and his professionalism.
Field Judge's understanding of the rules and overall game management
*
Clearly understood the rules and managed the game efficiently and effectively
Understood the rules, but did not manage the game as effectively
Managed the game well, but made bad call(s) that impacted the game
Made multiple mistakes impacting several plays both in rules application and management
Game management is knowing the rules, the overall status of the game, and the ability to use effective judgement given the situation.
Overall Comments about the Field Judge:
Side Judge Name
Side Judge communication
*
Outstanding
Above Average
Average
Below Average
Poor
Good communication is talking with other deep official and assisting with side line management. Demonstrating knowledge of the down, distance and status of ball at all times. Using proper signals to signify defensive player count and down.
Overall, how would you rate the presence of the Side Judge?
*
Outstanding
Above Average
Average
Below Average
Poor
Presence is overall appearance, ability to communicate with crew, and his professionalism.
Side Judge's understanding of the rules and overall game management
*
Clearly understood the rules and managed the game efficiently and effectively
Understood the rules, but did not manage the game as effectively
Managed the game well, but made bad call(s) that impacted the game
Made multiple mistakes impacting several plays both in rules application and management
Game management is knowing the rules, the overall status of the game, and the ability to use effective judgement given the situation.
Overall Comments about the Side Judge:
Clock Operator Name
Did you notice any clock errors during the game?
*
Yes
No
Did a clock error during the game require the clock to be reset?
*
Yes
No
Optional Comments about ECO:
Use this optional field to provide game specific comments or any overall comments